Your metrics love them. Your people don’t

Your metrics love them. Your people don’t

On paper, they’re the same leader. Two managers, two identical dashboards – both hit the number, both sitting pretty in the review. One of them has a team that would follow them into a burning building. The other has a team that flinches slightly every time that name lights up on their phones. And nothing on the dashboard can tell you which is which.

That’s the uncomfortable thing about the toxic high performer. They’re not bad at the job – they’re excellent at it, which is precisely why they keep getting promoted. They hit every target. They just hit them by quietly spending something the company never put on a report: trust. Their performance is high, but their team’s trust in them is low. So the numbers look wonderful, right up until the good people start leaving and nobody can quite say why.

The problem is that we’ve got beautiful instruments for half the picture and very little for the other half. Performance we measure to the decimal: speed, attainment, pipeline, output, and more. Trust? Not that much. So when two leaders post the same results – one building something durable, the other burning the furniture to keep the room warm – the dashboard rates them identically. If anything it rates the burner higher, because scorched earth is briefly very productive.

The better leader may post slightly worse numbers in the short run. Their performance is typically medium-to-high, and their team’s trust in them is high. They go a touch slower because they let people learn, they share the credit, they don’t manufacture the panic that squeezes out one more point. But on a spreadsheet that restraint reads as underperformance, whereas in reality it’s the only kind of performance that compounds.

So how do you measure trust?

You don’t – not the way you measure revenue. But you can read it, if you’re watching the right things instead of the screen. How fast does bad news travel upward: does a problem reach the leader while it’s still small, or at the post-mortem? What does the cc field look like on their team – lean, or does everyone copy everyone, because a cc is a receipt and receipts are what you keep when you don’t trust the outcome... Who’s gone quiet in meetings? And the bluntest instrument of all: who’s left, and were they any good?

None of those is a number you can chart, but every one of them is visible to anyone paying attention – and, they surface in the same place: how the team actually works together, meeting by meeting, week by week. Not in the annual survey. 

So when we promote only on the axis we can see, we risk staying blind to the one that actually decides whether a team survives its leader. Until trust has a reliable instrument, the toxic high performer will keep winning on points. But will the company win?

Leave a comment